Giving Tuesday: Ambition, Expectations, and the Work Ahead

Giving Tuesday is coming. Let’s talk about what to expect and what it takes to make the most of it.

About a third of charitable giving happens in the fourth quarter. Some estimates put roughly 10% in the final three days of December. That’s a lot of giving, but it doesn’t mean every organization will see a huge surge on Giving Tuesday.

What you can raise depends on your size, your individual donor community, your relationships, and the time and tools you have to reach people. Large organizations may have teams, data, segmentation, and established donor pipelines. For smaller organizations, the goal may be to build awareness, reconnect with supporters, and bring in a few gifts that carry momentum into December.

I loved year-end fundraising when I worked in large development shops. I loved the challenge of making a campaign for 76,000 people feel like a personal connection. The easy lesson everyone can benefit from is the importance of paying attention to the behaviors of your donors. I remember in my first six months on the job in 2012, people I knew kept saying some version of the same thing: “We want to give to Rugby, DCA, or the Rifle team, but nobody asks us.” This highlighted a central challenge that my very large shop was doing by solely focusing on the institutions priorities. We were failing to connect with our donors wishes and behaviors. We were making asks, but for some we were trying to reach it was for the wrong thing. This is a lesson everyone can learn from, along with the ability to educate your donors, but we will touch on that later.

So, here’s what I did. I took time, time being the key word, and tried something ambitious: a neutral holiday card with a lot of ways to give. It was a carefully segmented appeal- thanking donors, holding out people who had just newly made a gift with a special ask, and tailoring outreach for major gift prospects, annual donors, class giving, sports giving, clubs, lybunts (last year but not this year), sybunts (some year but not this year), and more.

Why? Because I know that it takes less dollars and effort to convert a gift from someone who is already engaged with your organization as a volunteer, donor, or supporter than one that is not. If someone drops from your mission- there is a reason and it’s most likely something you are not doing.

The ability to take risks and use mail, usually comes with a budget that can support the risk. This direct mail appeal cost more than the previous income from the last several campaigns together, so it was a risk, but worth it… by seven figures or twenty times the reward.

Let’s talk about crowdfunding, and that is kind of what #GT is these days… its small amounts of money, from seemingly a large amount of people, and in a short amount of time. You need to go into these moments knowing that the gifts are often smaller, so you aren’t going to roll up your big donors and engaged constituency in a general social media appeal.

I like #GT to reach new donors, but you have to be thoughtful about how to reach new donors without losing sight of larger prospects. Fundraising is a carefully planned support strategy with calendars and benchmarks. Fine-tuned, high revenue campaigns take years of testing, learning, and relationship-building. It is exciting to be able to test and try new things, but most organizations do not have time and resources for a robust individual campaign.

However, we still have to be relevant, share missions, engage supporters, and steward year-round, and being proactive in this annual campaign gives you valuable data to build upon. So, here’s what you can do:

  • Set a realistic goal. Look at your past results, the people you can reach, and the time you have.

  • Choose a story that connects. Show why the work matters to people who already know you, and help them see how others can connect, too.

  • Start with your community. Your volunteers, current donors, colleagues, and friends are people who already have some deeper connection to your work.

  • Make the ask clear. Tell people what you want to do and how their support will help make possible.

  • Stay present. Use social media to share the work, thank supporters, and invite people into the year-end effort, not only to post a donation link on one day.

  • Steward. If you are only reaching out to people to ask for something, you are are going to have a tough time keeping them engaged. Gratitude is a year long effort, even for the smallest teams.

If you’re a small organization, don’t measure your campaign against a large shop with a big staff, a mature donor file, and years of fundraising data. Set a SMART goal. Tell a story that feels true. Show up consistently. Then build from what you learn.

Giving Tuesday is one day. The work of inviting people into your mission continues through-out the year.

Now, go out and get it done! We wish you the best as you close out a year of impact, and begin plans for 2027.

Learn more at Mission Forward.

Next
Next

Veterans Day Update: House Passes Take Care of America's Veterans Act